If you’re anywhere near Western New York and you haven’t been to Muscoreil’s yet… You’re missing out. It’s more than just a bakery — it’s a dessert dreamland where every cookie, cupcake, and pie is made with love (and a little bit of magic). Whether you’re planning your first visit or just want to make sure you’re not missing any must-tries, we’ve got you covered.
Here’s your official guide on what to try at Muscoreil’s!
Cookies that Deserve a Standing Ovation
Mega Dipped Chocolate Chip
Think of your favorite childhood cookie, now dip it in chocolate and super-size it. Yep, that’s the Mega Dipped — a cookie so good, it might ruin all other cookies for you.
Mexican Wedding
Soft, melt-in-your-mouth, and impossible to eat just one. Pro tip: pair them with a hot coffee for an afternoon pick-me-up that feels like a hug. 
Sugar M&M Cookie
Bright, sweet, and colorful — this cookie is a whole mood. 
Cupcakes with Personality
White Almond Raspberry Swirl Cupcake
Almond buttercream and raspberry… it’s the cupcake equivalent of a rom-com ending — dramatic, satisfying, and full of heart.
Red Velvet Cupcake
Classic, rich, and topped with a dreamy swirl of cream cheese frosting. Basically, it’s self-care in cupcake form. 
Death by Chocolate Cupcake
We’re not saying it’ll changing your life… but we’re not not saying it either.
Pies to Write Home About
Dutch Caramel Apple Pie
Apples, cinnamon, and gooey caramel under a buttery crumble? Yes please.
Banana Cream Pie
Smooth, silky, and nostalgic in the best way. A fan favorite for a reason.
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie
Sweet and tart, just like your favorite rom-com heroine.
Cakes Worth Celebrating Any Day
Cassata Cake
Layers of light sponge, sweet ricotta, nuts, and cherries. It’s like a slice of Sicily, no passport required.
Chocolate Peanut Butter Cake
A rich combo that hits every time. Peanut butter lovers, you need this.
Carrot Cake
Spiced to perfection and topped with that dreamy cream cheese frosting. Grandma would approve.
Little Bites, Big Joy
Pastry Hearts
Buttery, flaky, and perfectly glazed. They’re a Buffalo favorite — and Muscoreil’s does them right.
Cake Pops
Adorable, giftable, and dangerously poppable. One is never enough.
La Dolce Ricotta
Sweet, delicate, and oh-so-Italian. Trust us — this is love at first bite.
Perfect Pairings
Grab a blueberry or lemon poppy seed muffin to go with your morning coffee, or snag a coffee cake for your next brunch gathering. Whatever your flavor vibe is, Muscoreil’s has the sweet companion to match it.
So, What Should You Try at Muscoreil’s?
Honestly? Everything. But if we had to narrow it down — start with a cupcake, grab a slice of pie, and toss in a cookie or two. Whether you’re celebrating a birthday, hosting a brunch, or just craving a treat after work, Muscoreil’s is here to make your day a little sweeter.
Swing by, say hi, and treat yourself. You deserve it.