Skip to content
Now Open In the Village of Lancaster! Wedding Consults Open Through 2027 Order Online For Pickup In-Store

Order online · Made to order

The bakery case

Everything we’re baking this week, ready to reserve for pickup at the shop in North Tonawanda. Each one is made fresh to order for your scheduled pickup.

The full case 71 items
Sort
  • Retail Desserts 4.6

    Baklava

    Layers of golden phyllo, crisp and honey-soaked, hold a filling of finely chopped walnuts packed edge…

  • Pies 4.7

    Banana Black Bottom

    A oreo crust tucked under fresh banana cream, all swirled over with clouds of hand-piped whipped…

  • Pies 4.9

    Banana Cream Pie

    Layers of ripe bananas and rich vanilla cream nestled in our flaky crust, finished with a…

  • Retail Desserts 4.8

    Bars

    Cut thick and tucked into their own paper liners, our bars come brownie-fudgy, coconut-loaded Hello Dolly,…

  • Holiday 4.5

    Basket Cake

    Piped in a basket-weave pattern of soft pastel buttercream and topped with a bouquet of hand-piped…

    Price range: $55.00 through $65.00
  • Pastry Trays 5.0

    Bereavement Tray

    A gentle tray for gathering the family together, includes mini muffins, coffee cake, pastry hearts, butter…

    Price range: $77.99 through $130.99
  • Cookies 4.4

    Biscotti

    Twice-baked the old way, so every slice comes out crisp enough for a good dunk in…

  • Pies 4.0

    Blueberry Pie

    A generous double crust baked until golden and sugar-dusted, with plump blueberries peeking through the vents.…

  • Cookie Trays & Tins 4.8

    Butter Cutout Tray

    A tray of our old-fashioned butter cutouts with butter icing. Arranged on a tray from 1…

    Price range: $24.99 through $106.99
  • Cookies 4.8

    Butter Cutouts

    Rolled from our old-fashioned butter cookie dough and cut by hand, then dipped in butter icing.…

  • Retail Desserts 4.5

    Cake pop - dozen

    A dozen cake pops dipped by hand and dressed up their own way, rainbow sprinkles, cookies-and-cream…

  • Retail Desserts 5.0

    Cake Slice

    Grab a slice and take your pick: white almond raspberry, chocolate ganache, carrot, or cassata with…

Baked from scratch
No mixes, no shortcuts. Everything is made by hand in our bakeries.
Made to order
Every order is made fresh to order for the pickup day you choose.
Pickup at the shop
Order for pickup at our North Tonawanda or Lancaster locations. We’ll have your box waiting for you.