Now Open In the Village of Lancaster! Wedding Consults Open Through 2027 Order Online For Pickup In-Store

Order online · Made to order

Cookie Trays & Tins

Everything we’re baking this week, ready to reserve for pickup at the shop in North Tonawanda. Each one is made fresh to order for your scheduled pickup.

Cookie Trays & Tins 4 items
Sort
  • Cookie Trays & Tins 4.8

    Butter Cutout Tray

    A tray of our old-fashioned butter cutouts with butter icing. Arranged on a tray from 1…

    Price range: $24.99 through $106.99
  • Cookie Trays & Tins 4.0

    Holiday Tray

    Price range: $71.49 through $111.99
  • Cookie Trays & Tins 5.0

    Italian Cookie Tray

    A colorful mix of our Italian cookies, hand-arranged on a doily-lined tray — 14 varieties including…

    Price range: $26.99 through $116.99
  • Cookie Trays & Tins 4.1

    Mixed Cookie Tray

    A little of everything from our case, arranged on one tray: Butter cutouts, assorted Italian and…

    Price range: $71.49 through $111.99
Baked from scratch
No mixes, no shortcuts. Everything is made by hand in our bakeries.
Made to order
Every order is made fresh to order for the pickup day you choose.
Pickup at the shop
Order for pickup at our North Tonawanda or Lancaster locations. We’ll have your box waiting for you.